Affiliate disclosure. Some links in this guide are affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
I’ve paid full retail for a designer handbag and regretted it. Eventually I figured out a way to make this little habit of mine more manageable. I sell the bags I don’t carry anymore and put the money toward the next one. I like to think of it as keeping it in the family. Sometimes I’ll spend a little extra if I’m really upgrading.
Take the nude Saint Laurent Cabas I bought secondhand. I loved that buttery leather, but I carried it only a handful of times because I was convinced I’d scratch it or get lipstick on it. (Apparently I can be trusted with a designer bag or a tube of lipstick, but both at once felt ambitious.) I sold it for what I paid and put the money toward a black caviar Chanel Mini Square flap.
I got lucky on the resale price. What stuck with me was how quickly I could tell which bag actually fit my life. If you’re shopping secondhand, start with a store that gives you enough information to make that call. Below are 12 places to look, with the authentication and return details I’d check before buying.
Resale shops and consignment
01 / THE HANDBAG EDIT
FASHIONPHILE
I would trust FASHIONPHILE with my life. I’ve bought and sold bags and other goodies with them, and I’ve only had great experiences. I bought my Louis Vuitton backpack from them and wear it almost every day. Their standards for authenticity and condition are why I’d start here. They back their inventory with a lifetime authenticity guarantee. You have 15 days from delivery to postmark an eligible return, so keep the tags on while you decide.
My Louis Vuitton backpack from FASHIONPHILE.–Emma
02 / THE HANDBAG EDIT
Yoogi’s Closet
Years ago I bought a beat-up Chanel tote from Yoogi’s Closet. It was cute for a bit, but I resold it pretty fast. The selection is smaller, so I’d check here after my usual favorites in case they happen to have the bag you want. Yoogi’s photographs the actual item and authenticates in-house. The 15-day return window starts when your order ships.
03 / THE HANDBAG EDIT
Rebag
I’ve bought one handbag from Rebag and the whole thing was pretty seamless. I trust their authentication. The offers on the selling side can feel low to me, but as a buyer I’ve seen decent prices. I’d wait for a sale before paying full price. For eligible U.S. orders, request a return within seven days of delivery. Standard return fees start at $25 and go up with the price of the bag.
04 / THE HANDBAG EDIT
myGemma
I’d trust myGemma on authenticity. I’ve sold jewelry to them and bought a watch I adore, and both were easy. I haven’t bought a bag from them yet, but they have a great selection. They authenticate in-house and include a certificate. Eligible returns have a 14-day window from delivery. Check the listing for final sale and keep the security tag attached while you look the bag over.
05 / THE HANDBAG EDIT
FWRD RENEW
I haven’t bought from FWRD RENEW, but I’ve noticed they have a good selection, especially if you’re looking for something from a more recent season. FWRD says its suppliers authenticate each piece and its team checks it again. I haven’t looked closely enough at the process to vouch for it myself. Check whether the bag qualifies for the standard 30-day return policy.
06 / THE HANDBAG EDIT
The RealReal
I’d pass on an expensive handbag from The RealReal. The selection is great and the prices can be competitive, but bags are final sale. I want to see what the wear actually looks like in person before I’m stuck with a bag. Customer stories about authenticity have made me cautious, too. If I’m spending thousands, I’d pay a little more at a shop I trust. Shoes are a different story. I’ve found hard-to-find designer pairs there at stellar prices, and eligible shoes can be returned. I haven’t sold through them.
Marketplaces and collectible bags
07 / THE HANDBAG EDIT
eBay
I bought my first Chanel flap bag from FashionHulu on eBay way back when it was only a couple thousand dollars. I had a great experience, but at today’s prices I’d probably go with one of the resale shops I trust more. I’m extra cautious about fakes and scams, and I don’t know how rigorous eBay’s checks are firsthand. eBay offers free authentication for eligible bags from covered brands at $500 and up, with a paid option on some bags from $200 to $499.99. Check the badge, seller reviews and return terms.
My first Chanel flap from eBay.–Emma
08 / THE HANDBAG EDIT
Poshmark
I bought this pink Jacquemus bag on Poshmark and later reposhed it there. I found my vintage Dior Saddle bag there, too. I’ve sold several designer pieces on Poshmark and had a great experience. Chanel shoes were my biggest sale, and I don’t think I’ve spent more than $800 on a purchase there. Select luxury items at $500 and up with the Authentication Included badge go to Poshmark for an in-person check before they ship to the buyer. I’d still be careful selling anything pricey. I’ve heard stories about buyers claiming a box arrived empty or an item arrived damaged, or sending back a fake. If you’re buying and something doesn’t match the listing, open a case within 72 hours of delivery, before accepting the order.
My vintage Dior Saddle bag from Poshmark.–Emma
09 / THE HANDBAG EDIT
Vestiaire Collective
I bought and sold several things on Tradesy, which Vestiaire later acquired. I wanted to include Vestiaire as an option, but I’d think twice before buying a very expensive bag here. You’re dealing with individual sellers as well as professional ones, so take listing descriptions with a grain of salt. Authenticated Shipping includes an in-person inspection when available, though I don’t know how extensive the checks are firsthand. Individual sellers generally don’t take change-of-mind returns. Professional sellers give you 14 days from delivery.
10 / THE HANDBAG EDIT
What Goes Around Comes Around
I browsed What Goes Around Comes Around in person in NYC back when it was a much smaller shop. It was really cute. I’ve never bought anything from them, but they have a good reputation and I’d look here for vintage Chanel. Their team authenticates in-house and provides a letter of authenticity. Eligible online purchases qualify for free returns. Final-sale items and items discounted by 30% or more are excluded.
11 / THE HANDBAG EDIT
Madison Avenue Couture
Madison Avenue Couture is the crème de la crème of resale sites for me. The selection of immaculate Hermès and Chanel bags is incredible, and I would trust their authentication with my life. For eligible online pre-owned purchases, request an exchange or store credit within 48 hours of delivery. New and never-used bags are generally final sale.
12 / THE HANDBAG EDIT
Sotheby’s
I’d put Sotheby’s right up there with Madison Avenue Couture for authentication. This is where I’d look for collectible Hermès and Chanel, especially if I had a particular leather, color or hardware in mind. Most Buy Now handbags are final sale. If you’re bidding at auction, factor the buyer’s premium into your budget before you bid.
Before you buy
Look for the wear you’d actually notice
Zoom in on corners, handles and the lining. Ask for a close-up if the listing doesn’t show the area you care about. Check dimensions and strap drop against a bag you already carry. Ask whether the bag comes with authentication paperwork, including any third-party certificate, and what’s included with it. Check for the original box and receipt, plus accessories such as the strap, dust bag, lock and keys.
Read the rules on that exact listing
Check who authenticates it, whether it’s final sale, when the return clock starts and what sending it back would cost. Keep the tags attached until you’ve looked it over.
Keep the payment on the platform
Read recent seller reviews and keep messages, photos and payment in the marketplace so there’s a record if something goes wrong.
The nude Cabas taught me to be honest about how I’ll use a bag. If I’m already worried about getting lipstick on it, I’m probably going to reach for something else. The black caviar flap was a better fit for me. Whatever your version of that bag looks like, I’d hold out for the one you’ll actually take out of the closet.
